Skip to Content (Press Enter)
Skip to Footer (Press Enter)

My store

The Paper Store Of Clifton
Shop now and get 20% off for later with Crown Rewards.
See details >
Get more perks when you start your free trial of Hallmark+.
Learn more >
Make a big deal of their big day.
Shop birthday >

Plush Toys

My Friend Jesus Stuffed Doll, 13"

My Friend Jesus Stuffed Doll, 13"

$16.99
695
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Mini Better Together Magnetic Plush Series 3 Mystery Box

Mini Better Together Magnetic Plush Series 3 Mystery Box

$8.99
Large My Friend Jesus Plush, 25.5"

Large My Friend Jesus Plush, 25.5"

$34.99
70
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Mini Better Together Magnetic Plush Series 2 Mystery Box

Mini Better Together Magnetic Plush Series 2 Mystery Box

$8.99
6
4.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Mother Mary Holding Baby Jesus Stuffed Doll, 12.75"

Mother Mary Holding Baby Jesus Stuffed Doll, 12.75"

$16.99
270
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Bluey Mini Plush Clip-On Toy, 4.75"

Bluey Mini Plush Clip-On Toy, 4.75"

$9.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Puppy Brite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Puppy Brite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

$7.99
Aurora Palm Pals Flo Watering Can Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Flo Watering Can Plush, 5"

$12.99
Aurora Palm Pals Woolly Lamb Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Woolly Lamb Plush, 5"

$6.99
Bluey Bingo Mini Plush Clip-On Toy, 4.5"

Bluey Bingo Mini Plush Clip-On Toy, 4.5"

$9.99
Better Together Disney Mickey and Friends Mini Mystery Magnetic Plush, 4"

Better Together Disney Mickey and Friends Mini Mystery Magnetic Plush, 4"

$12.99
Noah's Ark and Animals Plush Playset, 7 Pieces

Noah's Ark and Animals Plush Playset, 7 Pieces

$34.99
84
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora Palm Pals Galileo Congrats Star Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Galileo Congrats Star Plush, 5"

$12.99
Pillow Pets BBC Bluey Bingo Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets BBC Bluey Bingo Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
5" Squishmallows Scented Sea Creature Mini Plush in Mystery Bag

5" Squishmallows Scented Sea Creature Mini Plush in Mystery Bag

$10.00
Sonic the Hedgehog Plush, 8"

Sonic the Hedgehog Plush, 8"

$16.99
Aurora Palm Pals Deon Daisy Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Deon Daisy Plush, 5"

$12.99
Jonah and the Big Fish Stuffed Doll Set

Jonah and the Big Fish Stuffed Doll Set

$29.99
72
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Nintendo Luigi Plush, 8"

Nintendo Luigi Plush, 8"

$16.99
Pillow Pets Bluey Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Bluey Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Stormy Plush Doll, 8"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Stormy Plush Doll, 8"

$12.99
Aurora Palm Pals Amanita Mushroom Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Amanita Mushroom Plush, 5"

$12.99
Bluey Lila Plush, 8"

Bluey Lila Plush, 8"

$9.99
Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Light Skin Girl, 12"

Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Light Skin Girl, 12"

$39.99
18
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Musical Plush Sun Toss-Around Game With Light and Sound, 5.5"

Musical Plush Sun Toss-Around Game With Light and Sound, 5.5"

$16.99
23
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Nintendo Mario Plush, 8"

Nintendo Mario Plush, 8"

$16.99
Pillow Pets Nickelodeon SpongeBob SquarePants Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Nickelodeon SpongeBob SquarePants Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
Bluey Plush, 8"

Bluey Plush, 8"

$9.99
Bluey Chef Bingo Plush, 8"

Bluey Chef Bingo Plush, 8"

$9.99
Bluey Baby Bluey Plush, 8"

Bluey Baby Bluey Plush, 8"

$16.99
Nintendo Yoshi Plush, 8"

Nintendo Yoshi Plush, 8"

$16.99
Bluey Bingo Plush, 8"

Bluey Bingo Plush, 8"

$16.99
Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Boy, 12"

Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Boy, 12"

$39.99
5
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Dark Skin Girl, 12"

Little World Changers™ and Kind Culture Co. The Doll Kind Dark Skin Girl, 12"

$39.99
16
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Little Plush

$14.99
Aurora Palm Pals Betsy Chick Plush, 5"

Aurora Palm Pals Betsy Chick Plush, 5"

$9.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

$7.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Plush Doll, 8"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Plush Doll, 8"

$12.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Tickled Pink Plush Doll, 8"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Tickled Pink Plush Doll, 8"

$12.99
Pillow Pets Disney Winnie the Pooh Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Disney Winnie the Pooh Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
Pillow Pets Disney and Pixar Sulley Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Disney and Pixar Sulley Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
Bluey Socks Plush, 8"

Bluey Socks Plush, 8"

$16.99
Sonic the Hedgehog Shadow Plush, 8"

Sonic the Hedgehog Shadow Plush, 8"

$16.99
Nintendo Fire Mario Plush, 8"

Nintendo Fire Mario Plush, 8"

$16.99
Pillow Pets Disney Angel Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Disney Angel Plush Toy, 16"

$34.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Twink Plush Doll, 7"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Twink Plush Doll, 7"

$12.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Starlite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Starlite Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

$7.99
TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Twink Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

TLS Toy Rainbow Brite Twink Plush Backpack Clip, 4"

$7.99
8" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Little Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Little Plush

5" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Little Plush

$9.99
12" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Medium Plush

$24.99
5" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Mini Plush

$9.99
5" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Mini Plush

$9.99
Pillow Pets Disney Moana Pua Pig Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Disney Moana Pua Pig Plush Toy, 16"

$36.99
12" Squishmallows Pama Pink Strawberry Cake Pop Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Pama Pink Strawberry Cake Pop Medium Plush

$24.99
12" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries in Red Scarf Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries in Red Scarf Medium Plush

$24.99
Intelex Warmies Lavender-Scented Bread Plush, 13"

Intelex Warmies Lavender-Scented Bread Plush, 13"

$29.99
12" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Ansel Red Bag of Potato Chips Medium Plush

$24.99
12" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Townes Green Juice Medium Plush

$24.99
8" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries With Red Scarf Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries With Red Scarf Little Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Mini Plush

$9.99
Pillow Pets Garfield Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Garfield Plush Toy, 16"

$36.99
5" Squishmallows Pama Pink Strawberry Cake Pop Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Pama Pink Strawberry Cake Pop Mini Plush

$9.99
8" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Little Plush

$14.99
8" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Salim Green Pickle Little Plush

$14.99
5" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries With Red Scarf Mini Plush

5" Squishmallows Floyd French Fries With Red Scarf Mini Plush

$9.99
12" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Medium Plush

12" Squishmallows Gasten Strawberry Crepe With Drizzle Medium Plush

$24.99
8" Squishmallows Botera Sheltie Little Plush in Navy Hoodie

8" Squishmallows Botera Sheltie Little Plush in Navy Hoodie

$14.99
8" Squishmallows Pink Cake Pop Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Pink Cake Pop Little Plush

$14.99
Pillow Pets Minions Bob Plush Toy, 16"

Pillow Pets Minions Bob Plush Toy, 16"

$36.99
Pillow Pets Jumbo Bluey Plush Toy, 30"

Pillow Pets Jumbo Bluey Plush Toy, 30"

$109.99
Flat Jesus Take-Along Companion

Flat Jesus Take-Along Companion

$7.99
355
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
You’ve seen 72 of 72 products
Loading