Skip to Content (Press Enter)
Skip to Footer (Press Enter)

My store

The Paper Store Of Clifton
Shop now and get 20% off for later with Crown Rewards.
See details >
Get more perks when you start your free trial of Hallmark+.
Learn more >
Make a big deal of their big day.
Shop birthday >

Classic Stuffed Animals

Better Together Rose and Truffle Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25"

Better Together Rose and Truffle Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25"

$16.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Peanuts® Heart-to-Heart Floppy Snoopy Plush, 10"

Peanuts® Heart-to-Heart Floppy Snoopy Plush, 10"

$16.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Peanut Butter and Jelly Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Peanut Butter and Jelly Magnetic Plush, 5"

$16.99
399
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Hugs and Kisses Bear Plush, 8"

Hugs and Kisses Bear Plush, 8"

$9.99
Better Together Mac and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 4.73"

Better Together Mac and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 4.73"

$16.99
45
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 8"

Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 8"

$18.99
88
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Floppy Snoopy Plush, 11"

Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Floppy Snoopy Plush, 11"

$16.99
Better Together Series 4 Mystery Box Mini Magnetic Plush, 3.5"

Better Together Series 4 Mystery Box Mini Magnetic Plush, 3.5"

$8.99
1
3.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Strawberry and Banana Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

Better Together Strawberry and Banana Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

$16.99
Better Together Corn Dog and Cotton Candy Magnetic Plush Pair, 3"

Better Together Corn Dog and Cotton Candy Magnetic Plush Pair, 3"

$16.99
Harry Potter™ Hedwig™ Plush Gift Card Holder, 5"

Harry Potter™ Hedwig™ Plush Gift Card Holder, 5"

$9.99
Better Together Star Wars™ R2-D2™ and C-3PO™ Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound, 6.25" H

Better Together Star Wars™ R2-D2™ and C-3PO™ Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound, 6.25" H

$29.99
Better Together Disney Mickey and Minnie Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Disney Mickey and Minnie Magnetic Plush, 5"

$22.99
Better Together Burger and Fries Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Burger and Fries Magnetic Plush, 5"

$16.99
422
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Peanuts® Snoopy Plush Gift Card Holder, 4.2"

Peanuts® Snoopy Plush Gift Card Holder, 4.2"

$9.99
2
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Mini Better Together Mystery Box Magnetic Plush, Series 1

Mini Better Together Mystery Box Magnetic Plush, Series 1

$8.99
7
4.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Cherry Pie and Ice Cream Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

Better Together Cherry Pie and Ice Cream Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

$16.99
Peanuts® Beagle Scouts Floppy Snoopy Plush, 10"

Peanuts® Beagle Scouts Floppy Snoopy Plush, 10"

$16.99
6
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Gilmore Girls Lorelai and Rory Magnetic Plush Pair, 4.75" H

Better Together Gilmore Girls Lorelai and Rory Magnetic Plush Pair, 4.75" H

$22.99
Peanuts® Snoopy and Woodstock Hugging Stuffed Animals, 10"

Peanuts® Snoopy and Woodstock Hugging Stuffed Animals, 10"

$29.99
59
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Peanuts Joe Cool Woodstock Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Peanuts Joe Cool Woodstock Little Plush

$24.99
Better Together Pretzel and Cheese Dip Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Pretzel and Cheese Dip Magnetic Plush, 5"

$14.99
126
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Takeout Box and Fortune Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

Better Together Takeout Box and Fortune Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

$16.99
3
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Milk and Cookie Magnetic Plush, 6"

Better Together Milk and Cookie Magnetic Plush, 6"

$16.99
372
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Pancakes and Syrup Magnetic Plush, 7"

Better Together Pancakes and Syrup Magnetic Plush, 7"

$16.99
38
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Hot Dog and Freeze Pop Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5"

Better Together Hot Dog and Freeze Pop Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5"

$16.99
Better Together Chips and Salsa Magnetic Plush, 5.5"

Better Together Chips and Salsa Magnetic Plush, 5.5"

$16.99
62
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Reza Latte Squirrel Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Reza Latte Squirrel Little Plush

$14.99
Better Together Doughnut and Latte Magnetic Plush, 7"

Better Together Doughnut and Latte Magnetic Plush, 7"

$16.99
8
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Sanrio Pink Hello Kitty Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Sanrio Pink Hello Kitty Little Plush

$19.99
Better Together Pizza and Ranch Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

Better Together Pizza and Ranch Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

$16.99
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Nickelodeon SpongeBob and Patrick Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.75"

Better Together Nickelodeon SpongeBob and Patrick Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.75"

$22.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Backpack Clip

3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Backpack Clip

$8.99
Better Together BLT and Pickle Magnetic Plush Pair, 4"

Better Together BLT and Pickle Magnetic Plush Pair, 4"

$16.99
8" Squishmallows Harry Potter Hedwig White Owl Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Harry Potter Hedwig White Owl Little Plush

$19.99
8" Squishmallows Sunny Yellow Honey Bee in Hat Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Sunny Yellow Honey Bee in Hat Little Plush

$14.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Capybara Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Capybara Plush

$29.99
Better Together Peanuts® Snoopy and Woodstock Magnetic Plush, 5.25"

Better Together Peanuts® Snoopy and Woodstock Magnetic Plush, 5.25"

$22.99
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Peanuts® Woodstock With Flower Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

Peanuts® Woodstock With Flower Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

$12.99
248
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Sushi and Soy Sauce Magnetic Plush, 5.25"

Better Together Sushi and Soy Sauce Magnetic Plush, 5.25"

$16.99
60
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Avocado and Toast Magnetic Plush, 5"

Better Together Avocado and Toast Magnetic Plush, 5"

$16.99
234
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Rutanya Blueberry Cow Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Rutanya Blueberry Cow Little Plush

$14.99
Big Sister Unicorn Plush, 12"

Big Sister Unicorn Plush, 12"

$29.99
Better Together Steak and Potato Magnetic Plush, 4.25"

Better Together Steak and Potato Magnetic Plush, 4.25"

$16.99
40
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Keroppi Plush Backpack Clip

3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Keroppi Plush Backpack Clip

$8.99
Intelex Warmies Black Cat Scented Stuffed Animal, 15"

Intelex Warmies Black Cat Scented Stuffed Animal, 15"

$29.99
Better Together SEGA Sonic the Hedgehog™ and Tails Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.2"

Better Together SEGA Sonic the Hedgehog™ and Tails Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.2"

$22.99
8" Squishmallows Eitan Matcha Red Panda With Boba Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Eitan Matcha Red Panda With Boba Little Plush

$14.99
Better Together Croissant and Butter Magnetic Plush Pair, 2.5"

Better Together Croissant and Butter Magnetic Plush Pair, 2.5"

$16.99
Large Better Together Disney Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

Large Better Together Disney Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Magnetic Plush Pair, 11"

$39.99
Better Together Spaghetti and Meatball Magnetic Plush, 4.75"

Better Together Spaghetti and Meatball Magnetic Plush, 4.75"

$16.99
39
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio My Melody Plush Backpack Clip

3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio My Melody Plush Backpack Clip

$8.99
Snoopy Lying Down

Snoopy Lying Down

$24.95
187
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Ham and Pineapple Magnetic Plush Pair, 7"

Better Together Ham and Pineapple Magnetic Plush Pair, 7"

$16.99
Intelex Warmies Sloth Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

Intelex Warmies Sloth Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

$11.99
Better Together Teacup and Macaron Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5"

Better Together Teacup and Macaron Cookie Magnetic Plush Pair, 3.5"

$16.99
Better Together Minecraft Baby Zombie and Chicken Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H

Better Together Minecraft Baby Zombie and Chicken Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H

$22.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Black and White Cow Stuffed Animal, 13"

Warmies Heatable Scented Black and White Cow Stuffed Animal, 13"

$29.99
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Hot Dog and S'More Magnetic Plush, 4"

Better Together Hot Dog and S'More Magnetic Plush, 4"

$16.99
45
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Disney and Pixar Monsters, Inc. Mike and Sulley Magnetic Plush, 6"

Better Together Disney and Pixar Monsters, Inc. Mike and Sulley Magnetic Plush, 6"

$22.99
3
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
10" Squishmallows HugMees Bluey Chilli Plush

10" Squishmallows HugMees Bluey Chilli Plush

$19.99
Disney Mickey Mouse Plush Gift Card Holder

Disney Mickey Mouse Plush Gift Card Holder

$9.99
Better Together Broccoli and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75"

Better Together Broccoli and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75"

$16.99
27
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Deer Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

Baby Deer Stuffed Animal, 6.5"

$12.99
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Intelex Warmies Elephant Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

Intelex Warmies Elephant Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

$14.99
Intelex Warmies Axolotl Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 2"

Intelex Warmies Axolotl Junior Scented Stuffed Animal, 2"

$14.99
Aurora World Palm Pals Wizard Pig Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Wizard Pig Plush, 5"

$12.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Celestino Spotted Highland Cow Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Celestino Spotted Highland Cow Little Plush

$14.99
Aurora World Palm Pals Sly Fox Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Sly Fox Plush, 5"

$12.99
4
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
Warmies Heatable Scented Soccer Ball Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Soccer Ball Plush

$29.99
Better Together Cinnamon Roll and Orange Juice Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

Better Together Cinnamon Roll and Orange Juice Magnetic Plush Pair, 5"

$16.99
3
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Harry Potter™ Hedwig™ Stuffed Animal, 9"

Harry Potter™ Hedwig™ Stuffed Animal, 9"

$19.99
9
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Ketchup, Mustard and Relish Magnetic Plush Trio, 7.5"

Better Together Ketchup, Mustard and Relish Magnetic Plush Trio, 7.5"

$24.99
Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Better Together Jack & Sally Magnetic Plush, 5"

Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Better Together Jack & Sally Magnetic Plush, 5"

$22.99
8
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora World Palm Pals Chomps Shark Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Chomps Shark Plush, 5"

$12.99
2
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

Baby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

$18.99
133
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Intelex Warmies Golden Dog Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

Intelex Warmies Golden Dog Scented Stuffed Animal, 9"

$14.99
Disney Winnie the Pooh Soft Felt Stuffed Animal, 11"

Disney Winnie the Pooh Soft Felt Stuffed Animal, 11"

$29.99
99
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Aurora World Palm Pals Meow Kitty Plush, 5"

Aurora World Palm Pals Meow Kitty Plush, 5"

$12.99
12
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Bunny Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

Baby Bunny Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

$18.99
4
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
10" Squishmallows Peanuts Beagle Scouts Woodstock Medium Plush

10" Squishmallows Peanuts Beagle Scouts Woodstock Medium Plush

$24.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Basketball Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Basketball Plush

$29.99
Peanuts® Snoopy Stuffed Animal With Corduroy Ears, 10.5"

Peanuts® Snoopy Stuffed Animal With Corduroy Ears, 10.5"

$29.99
27
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Disney Lilo & Stitch Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound, 5.75" H

Better Together Disney Lilo & Stitch Magnetic Plush Pair With Sound, 5.75" H

$29.99
Better Together Star Wars™ Han Solo™ and Chewbacca™ Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

Better Together Star Wars™ Han Solo™ and Chewbacca™ Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5"

$22.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Sunshine Recordable Plush, 10"

Sunshine Recordable Plush, 10"

$29.99
7
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
Warmies Hugs Heatable Scented Puppy Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

Warmies Hugs Heatable Scented Puppy Stuffed Animals, Set of 2

$29.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Cinnamoroll Plush Backpack Clip

3.5" Squishmallows Sanrio Cinnamoroll Plush Backpack Clip

$8.99
Silver Baby Fox Stuffed Animal, 8"

Silver Baby Fox Stuffed Animal, 8"

$18.99
Large Better Together Taco and Hot Sauce Magnetic Plush, 16"

Large Better Together Taco and Hot Sauce Magnetic Plush, 16"

$39.99
13
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Baby Cow Stuffed Animal, 6"

Baby Cow Stuffed Animal, 6"

$12.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
8" Squishmallows Harry Potter Hermione Granger Little Plush

8" Squishmallows Harry Potter Hermione Granger Little Plush

$19.99
Large Giving Bear Stuffed Animal, 16"

Large Giving Bear Stuffed Animal, 16"

$34.99
568
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Better Together Sesame Street Bert and Ernie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H

Better Together Sesame Street Bert and Ernie Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25" H

$22.99
Better Together Back to the Future Doc and Marty McFly Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5" H

Better Together Back to the Future Doc and Marty McFly Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.5" H

$22.99
Warmies Heatable Scented Chick Plush

Warmies Heatable Scented Chick Plush

$29.99
Better Together Grapes and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75"

Better Together Grapes and Cheese Magnetic Plush, 5.75"

$16.99
7
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Kitten Stuffed Animal, 7.2"

Kitten Stuffed Animal, 7.2"

$18.99
Disney Minnie Mouse Plush, 11"

Disney Minnie Mouse Plush, 11"

$29.99
You’ve seen 99 of 309 products
Show more products
Loading